Skip to content

Captain Cookie & The Milkman

CUISINE: Ice Cream | Dessert

PLACE DETAILS: Website | Twitter | Facebook

Also operates brick and mortar location. Previously available at Thomas Foolery, which closed in December 2015 and then announced new ownership in February 2016.


Nutella Cookies with Vanilla Ice Cream and Ginger Molasses Cookies with Maple Bacon Ice Cream (Affirmed)

The Nutella cookies “tasted like Nutella” and “were chocolatey but not overwhelmingly sweet” with a “soft and chewy” center and a “nice, crisp shell.” The vanilla ice cream was as “expected.” The ginger molasses cookies were “rich while not too gingery” with a “beautiful coating” of granulated sugar. The maple bacon ice cream was a “surprise” and “chock-full of bacon pieces.” For the full review, see In re Captain Cookie & The Milkman at Thomas Foolery, 23 Catt. 2 (2013).